On greatest hits collections

Nearly every greatest hits collection has a problem. Problems arise owing to constraints. There's the high-level constraint, of course—how to pick favorite tracks. And some collections get this wrong! But there are constraints beyond this, too. There were the different labels jockeying for influence over an artist's discography, the artist's own (sometimes wrong-headed) preferences, the … Continue reading On greatest hits collections

On songs that send us somewhere, or, on the song atlas

It shouldn't surprise me, but it always does: some songs end up "fixed" to a place in my personal history, the record equivalent of Proust's madeline, a cue that sends me somewhere back in my personal geography. Together, I think of these fixed songs as a personal "song atlas." "Sun" by The Hotelier I hear … Continue reading On songs that send us somewhere, or, on the song atlas

On how it’s hard to listen to Frightened Rabbit

If you’d asked me my favorite band back in 2017, I’d have probably replied Frightened Rabbit. (Or maybe Drive-By Truckers.) But following the suicide of leader Scott Hutchison in 2018, I found it hard to listen to their work. If you don’t know Frightened Rabbit, think of a miserablist Arcade Fire, purveyors of anthemic indie … Continue reading On how it’s hard to listen to Frightened Rabbit

On the polished structure of Alvvays’ “Blue Rev”

The first time I listened to Alvvays' album Blue Rev, I made it through half the album before moving on. The MBV-style waves of distortion and fuzz (on many songs) made for a tough listen—tough in that the mix insists on your attention. In December, when all the best-of-year lists start rolling out, I was … Continue reading On the polished structure of Alvvays’ “Blue Rev”

On wondering whether the Beatles and Michelangelo have something in common

The other night, I started rewatching Peter Jackson's Get Back documentary, on the Beatles' infamous Get Back sessions of 1969. Jackson's documentary has become infamous in its own right a year after its release—owning mainly to its eight-hour running time, but also to its reliance on snatches of dialogue that can only be understood by … Continue reading On wondering whether the Beatles and Michelangelo have something in common